Words and Images: The Connection Between Artist Charles Demuth and Poet William Carlos Williams
Words and Images: The Connection Between Artist Charles Demuth and Poet William Carlos Williams
Grade Levels
Course, Subject
Rationale
Vocabulary
Modernist Poetry- type of poetry that has no prescribed meter or rhyme. This type of poetry was first created in the mid 1800"s.
Symbols- something that stands for or suggests something else by reason of relationship, association, convention, or accidental resemblance
Elements of Art- line, shape, color, value, form, space, and texture
Depth- the direct linear measurement from front to back
Distortion- a lack of proportionality in an image resulting from defects in the optical system
Interpretation-to explain according to prior knowledge and surrounding factual information
Expression- an act, process, or instance of representing in a medium
Analyze- to study or determine the nature and relationship of the parts of something
Basic linear perspective- the technique or process of representing (on a plane or curved surface) the spatial relationship of objects as they might appear to the eye
Fragmentation- the process of making something incomplete or disjointed
Mood- the expression of a conscious state of mind found in art, literature, music, and dance
Analogous color- colors that sit side-by-side on the color wheel
Complementary color- colors that sit opposite on the color wheel
Principles of art- contrast, rhythm, unity, movement, emphasis, pattern, balance
Transparency- the property of transmitting light through its surface and allowing one to see through it
Objectives
1. Students will explore connections between modern poetry and visual art style and form.
2. Students will experience semantic language in visual art through symbols (both direct and indirect) and the layers of these symbols.
3. Students will research the similarities and connections between the poetry of Williams Carlos Williams and Charles DeMuth.
4. Students will implement critiquing formats in visual art.
5. Students will break down modern poetry into basic elements similar to those found in visual art.
6. Students will break a painting down into its basic elements using the elements of design.
7. Students will draw connections between the written word and the visual symbol.
8. Students will use brainstorming techniques to write a modernist poem about an everyday object or experience.
9. Students will use basic design elements to produce a thumbnail sketch that is a visual representation of what they wrote.
10. Students will represent their poems through the use of visual symbols.
11. Students will use basic one and two point linear perspective to manipulate their first thumbnail sketch.
12. Students will learn how to color blend using analogous color schemes.
13. Students will assess their personally created artwork and poem using a rubric.
Lesson Essential Question(s)
How do artists work in collaboration?
How are artists influenced by other artists and ideas?
Why do artists create?
How do artists assess their work at each stage of their artistic process?
How does interaction with text provoke thinking and response?
Duration
This lesson will take about ten 45 minute classes
Materials
The poem The Figure Five by William Carlos Williams
The artwork The Figure Five in Gold by Charles Demuth
Red Wheelbarrow by William Carlos Williams
sticky notepaper
pencils
erasers
permanent markers
miscellanesous everyday objects
brainstorming graphic organizer
rubric
oil pastels
q-tips
rulers
Suggested Instructional Strategies
W: | Students will have examples that have been done in the past to use as springboards for their ideas. They will also receive a rubric at the beginning of this lesson which outlines what is to be produced and how it will be graded. |
H: | Students will experience both forms of art simultaneously. They will see the Figure Five in Gold by Demuth while teachers and students read the Figure Five by Williams Carlos Williams. They will also see a spectrum of visual demonstrations to guide them. |
E: | This lesson has a variety of sensory cues that will allow students to experience poetry and visual art in a variety of ways. Additionally, to guide the writing, students will be able to select their own objects as well as a graphic organizer that best suits their learning style. |
R: | Due to the nature of this inter-art analogy lesson, the development of both art forms uses continual revisiting, revising, and rethinking of the poem and the artwork. Both art forms should develop and emerge together. |
E: | From the presentation of the essential question at the beginning of this lesson until the completion of the assessment rubric at the end of this lesson there will be continuous self evaluation. |
T: |
Individual selection of a graphic organizer and a common object will be tailored to meet student abilities. This would be for the writing of the Minimalist Poem. Other ways to differentiate instruction are: In the case of gifted learners, students could go to “The Artchive” and look up Charles Demuth. While students are in that site they will see highlighted key words that relate to Demuth and the American Modernist movement. After investigation, these students could write a brief synopsis about how the American Modernist Movement was part of a larger International avant-garde movement and compare/contrast the two styles. In the case of a visually impaired student a textural collage could be made with various materials, such as bubble wrap, faux fur, sandpaper, other embossed textures, corrugated cardboard, duct tape, etc. Tracers could be used to cut out shapes made with poster board stapled to the textured surface so that the student could cut slowly by touch. For the ADHD learner, lessons can be broken into smaller workable sections that include a “website break” where they search for other artworks by Demuth. The flexibility to allow controlled movement from one task to the next allows student concentration on tasks to be continually refocused in new and revisited ways. For the student who has trouble with word recognition and writing, a word bank that uses flash cards could be created with the cards perhaps being color coded according to the word and the part of speech. |
O: | Opportunities for teacher modeling and scaffolding exist throughout the lesson. Completion of the project will require individual performance accompanied by teacher, peer and self review. |
Prior knowledge/Skills
Students should have prior instruction about symbol use in visual art and ways in which meaning about a work of art is derived through design and symbol use.
Instructional Procedures
Day One/Two
The question "How are visual artists influenced by other types of artists" will be posed, focusing on developing a definition of visual harmony. Students will write sticky note responses to the question and paste them on a board.
Preparation for the sticky note responses can include discussion of the word “harmony” and relational words like “dissonance” and “unison.” Musical examples of these concepts can be performed in a variety of ways and discussions of personal relationships (family harmony, thinking in unison, etc.) using these terms can be explored.
Sticky note responses will become a catalyst for class discussion and formation of a class definition for visual harmony.
Using a white board or other presentational method, demonstrate unison, dissonance and harmony in art by using the elements of art.
- Take a circle and put another circle inside-harmony
- Take the circle and put a triangle interjecting into it-dissonance
- Circle on top of a circle-unison
- Ask students to give more examples of unison, dissonance, harmony as they relate to the elements of art
An optional way to present concepts toward learning visual harmony:
LEARNING STATIONS:
Station 1: Keyboard
Two keyboards will be used to play a series of chords that feature major and minor harmonies. Students will select color strips to match the individual chords they are hearing (one color for major and one color for minor) and place them in the order that they are hearing the chords, matching both color and sound with the concepts of dissonance and consonance.
Station 2: Guitar
Two guitars will be used. One plays a melodic line and one plays a series of chords.
When the definition has been established, a print of the "Figure Five In Gold" will be displayed and students will use a teacher-developed handout to read the poem "The Great Figure" by William Carlos Williams. The poem should be read three times out loud, first as a unison reading with subsequent expressive readings in front of the class from individual class members. Brainstorming sessions about the correlation between the visual representations that Charles Demuth painted and the poem should take place after each reading. Students should make key entries about how the subject is portrayed in both the poem and the painting, noting compositional elements that allude to symbolic references and text used within the work.
Preparation for subsequent lessons: students will be asked to select and bring an everyday object to class, or the teacher can provide unique and interesting objects around which poetry and visual art work can be developed.
Day Two/Three
The questions "How Do Artists Work in Collaboration?” and “What kinds of connections can be made between poetry and visual art?” will be posed. Students will be given a project plan/assessment rubric that relates to the artistic works to be created in the upcoming lessons. The teacher will present an overview of the project plan/assessment rubric.
Figure Five in Gold Project Design and Assessment Rubric |
||||
|
Advanced |
Proficient |
Basic |
In Progress |
Poem |
Poem is presented following a minimalist design and text relates to the shape, color, function and sounds of the selected object |
Poem design has minimalist qualities and most of the text relates to the shape, color, function and sounds of the selected object |
Poem design lacks minimalist qualities and only some of the text relates to the shape, color, function and sounds of the selected object |
Poem lacks a sense of minimalist design and/or the text relationship to the shape, color, function and sounds of the selected object is vague |
Preliminary Sketches |
Three sketches of a selected object are completed from three unique and diverse different perspectives |
Three sketches of a selected object are completed from three different perspectives |
Three sketches of a selected object are completed from similar perspectives |
Fewer than three sketches of a selected object are completed |
Final Project |
Initials are incorporated three times, demonstrating mastery of one point perspective Oil pastel techniques reflect a strong understanding of contour as it relates to analogous color mixing Project has all miscellaneous pieces swept off and all of the objects are outlined (demonstrating line quality) with permanent marker |
Initials are incorporated three times but perspective needs sense of depth Oil pastel techniques reflect a consistent understanding of analogous color mixing Project has all miscellaneous pieces swept off and most of the objects are outlined with permanent marker |
Initials are incorporated fewer than three times and/or lack perspective Oil pastel techniques reflect an inconsistent understanding of analogous color mixing Project has all miscellaneous pieces swept off and some of the objects are outlined with permanent marker |
Initials are incorporated fewer than three times and/or are portrayed only in a linear fashion Oil pastel techniques reflect little understanding of analogous color mixing techniques, or are incomplete Project does not have all miscellaneous pieces swept off and not all of the objects are outlined with permanent marker |
Work Habits |
Engagement in the project included whole class time and beyond |
Engagement in the project included whole class time |
Engagement in the project included a majority of class time |
Engagement in the project was minimal |
The question "What types of experiences do artists and poets use as sources of inspiration" will be posed. Students will use the everyday object selected and write a minimalist poem (using Williams "The Great Figure" as a model) about that object.
Several minimalist poems and minimalist artworks should be prepared for analysis of design and form that would relate to visual art creation (i.e., repetition of text=repetition in the visual art work, etc.).
Day Four
The teacher will lead a review about one point perspective. Students will then sketch three views of the chosen object. Holding the objects in positions suspended in the air or rotating them so that undersides and foreshortened sides are made clearer can serve as options for student sketching.
As students are working the teacher will be circulating throughout the room pointing out to students where their work lies within the rubric and how to make adjustments to advance both their poems and their sketches.
Day 5
Students will select their favorite view of their chosen object and enlarge it onto oak tag. Students will incorporate their initials or a nickname into their artwork three times (just like Charles Demuth's "Figure Five in Gold" has three sets of initials and names).
As students are working, the teacher will circulate through the room with sketch paper in hand to offer ideas about depth perception, lettering, composition manipulation and other ideas that might arise.
The teacher will continue to circulate throughout the room pointing out to students where their work lies within the rubric and how to make adjustments to advance both their poems and their sketches.
Days 6 thru 10
Students will work on drawing, outlining, and coloring with oil pastels. Before the end of day five, the teacher will present a demonstration showing color mixing with analogous colors.
The teacher will continue to circulate throughout the room pointing out to students where their work lies within the rubric and how to make adjustments to advance both their poems and their sketches.
Prior to the end of the final day, students will utilize a self-assessment rubric.
Formative Assessment
Figure Five in Gold Project Design and Assessment Rubric |
||||
|
Advanced |
Proficient |
Basic |
In Progress |
Poem |
Poem is presented following a minimalist design and text relates to the shape, color, function and sounds of the selected object |
Poem design has minimalist qualities and most of the text relates to the shape, color, function and sounds of the selected object |
Poem design lacks minimalist qualities and only some of the text relates to the shape, color, function and sounds of the selected object |
Poem lacks a sense of minimalist design and/or the text relationship to the shape, color, function and sounds of the selected object is vague |
Preliminary Sketches |
Three sketches of a selected object are completed from three unique and diverse different perspectives |
Three sketches of a selected object are completed from three different perspectives |
Three sketches of a selected object are completed from similar perspectives |
Fewer than three sketches of a selected object are completed |
Final Project |
Initials are incorporated three times, demonstrating mastery of one point perspective Oil pastel techniques reflect a strong understanding of contour as it relates to analogous color mixing Project has all miscellaneous pieces swept off and all of the objects are outlined (demonstrating line quality) with permanent marker |
Initials are incorporated three times but perspective needs sense of depth Oil pastel techniques reflect a consistent understanding of analogous color mixing Project has all miscellaneous pieces swept off and most of the objects are outlined with permanent marker |
Initials are incorporated fewer than three times and/or lack perspective Oil pastel techniques reflect an inconsistent understanding of analogous color mixing Project has all miscellaneous pieces swept off and some of the objects are outlined with permanent marker |
Initials are incorporated fewer than three times and/or are portrayed only in a linear fashion Oil pastel techniques reflect little understanding of analogous color mixing techniques, or are incomplete Project does not have all miscellaneous pieces swept off and not all of the objects are outlined with permanent marker |
Work Habits |
Engagement in the project included whole class time and beyond |
Engagement in the project included whole class time |
Engagement in the project included a majority of class time |
Engagement in the project was minimal |
Related Materials & Resources
Multiple web pages offer information about both the poet and the artist:
http://www.wisdomportal.com/Christmas/Figure5InGold.html
http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/works-of-art/49.59.1
http://www.poets.org/poet.php/prmPID/119
Mark Harden’s Artchive http://artchive.com/
Internet resources can be used to create the following:
A handout about Charles Demuth and William Carlos Williams
The Figure Five poem by William Carlos Williams
The Red Wheelbarrow by William Carlos Williams
The Figure Five in Gold by Charles Demuth
Other works by Charles Demuth showing his abstraction
The Guitar by Federico García Lorca
translated by Cola Franzen
The weeping of the guitar
begins.
The goblets of dawn
are smashed.
The weeping of the guitar
begins.
Useless
to silence it.
Impossible
to silence it.
It weeps monotonously
as water weeps
as the wind weeps
over snowfields.
Impossible
to silence it.
It weeps for distant
things.
Hot southern sands
yearning for white camellias.
Weeps arrow without target
evening without morning
and the first dead bird
on the branch.
Oh, guitar!
Heart mortally wounded
by five swords.
The home of Charles Demuth in Lancaster, PA (If your school is local, field trips to the home are available)