Skip to Main Content

Dirt versus Soil

Lesson Plan

Dirt versus Soil

Objectives

In this lesson, students will conduct investigations to determine what is in soil and how it differs from dirt. They will identify the components of soil and how it contains both living and nonliving materials. Students will:

  • use models to represent layers of soil found on the earth.

  • observe nonliving material in soil.

  • identify what soil is made of.

Essential Questions

Vocabulary

  • Dirt: Loose earth or soil.

  • Organic Material: Having to do with or coming from living things.

  • Soil: The top layer of the earth’s surface.

Duration

30–45 minutes/2 class periods (at least 1 week for observing a bean seed’s growth)

Prerequisite Skills

Prerequisite Skills haven't been entered into the lesson plan.

Materials

  • large resealable plastic bag, one per class

  • small resealable plastic bag, one per student

  • goggles, one per student

  • clear plastic container used in Lesson 1

  • two clear 1-liter soda bottles per group

  • 1 cup of potting soil

  • ½ cup of rock material

  • 2 cups water

  • funnel

  • Rock and Soil Venn Diagram (S-3-3-2_Rock and Soil Venn Diagram.doc)

  • potting soil, 1 cup per student group

  • sand, 1 cup per student group

  • Dirt Observation Sheet (S-3-3-2_Dirt Observation Sheet.doc)

Related Unit and Lesson Plans

Related Materials & Resources

The possible inclusion of commercial websites below is not an implied endorsement of their products, which are not free, and are not required for this lesson plan.

Formative Assessment

  • View
    • Monitor and question students as they work in groups to create soil by adding nonliving materials.

    • Monitor students’ understanding that material breaks down to create soil. Also, listen to responses to discussion questions and monitor student responses on observation sheets.

    • Monitor students’ understanding that soil contains living and nonliving parts.

    • Observe whether students correctly respond to questions on worksheets and in discussions.

Suggested Instructional Supports

  • View
    Scaffolding, Active Engagement, Modeling, Explicit Instruction
    W:

    In this lesson students will be using the created soil containing only rock particles and adding organic material such as dried leaves, sticks, and sand. They will conduct investigations to understand the recipe for soil.

    H:

    Students will be engaged in a nature walk around the school. They will collect various organic materials to combine with the rock material to form another type of soil.

    E:

    Through hands-on investigations, students observe various types of soil around their area. They will observe that soil has parts that make it a renewable source. Through student journals, observation sheets, and class discussion they will understand that soils with a balanced mixture are best for living things.

    R:

    Students will display an understanding of soil by creating new soil samples by adding decomposing organic material. Students will use containers of soil to separate the layers of soil to identify the texture and type of components in the soil. Formative assessments will be done through teacher observation and student responses on investigation sheets. Students will record observations and answer questions following each investigation.

    E:  
    T:

    Using large groups, partners, small group, and independent work, students are able to develop an understanding of soil and its components. Students will observe local soil found in the schoolyard.

    O:

    This lesson allows the teacher to connect the learning in a personal way by having students weather rocks and add ingredients to create a soil sample that contains good soil.

Instructional Procedures

  • View
    Activity 1, Day 1

    Show students the containers or layered rock used in Lesson 1. Ask students if this looks like soil. Tell students they are going to take a walking trip outside to collect some material. Note: Go over safety rules to follow such as:

    • Do not pick up any material without my permission.”

    • Wash your hands after you return from the walk.”

    Take students outside for a walk. Instruct students that they are looking for dried leaves, small sticks, twigs, and small rocks.

    • When they find some material they are to let you know and you allow them to collect or you will collect the material.

    • Place all material in the resealable plastic bag. When filled, return to the classroom.

    In this activity students will take the layered rock they have from Lesson 1 and combine with material found during their walk. Pour out the water from the container slowly, leaving the layered material only. You may pour the contents of the bottle into a paper plate or cut the container and scoop the material out. Allow the material to dry or pat dry with paper towels. Say, “We are going to add all of these dried leaves, twigs, sticks, small rocks, and other material we collected from outside to the layered material we made earlier.” Give each student a small resealable plastic bag and place a small amount of the gathered material inside. Tell each student they are going to carefully crush their material into even smaller pieces. Remind students to be careful not to tear the bags. Add some of the layered material from Lesson 1 to each of the student bags. Tell students to carefully begin to crush the material so that it breaks down into smaller pieces. Ask, “What does it look like we are doing to the material in the bag?” Students should begin to relate the concept of weathering or breaking down of earth material.

    Give students a paper plate and have them place a small amount of the material on the plate. Have students observe the content and record their observations in their student journals. Ask, “Has the material in the bag changed? What caused it to change? How was this activity like what might happen in the natural world? What can we call what is in the bag? What type of material was added? Was the material living material or nonliving material?” Note: Make sure students have a good understanding that dirt is under fingernails and on their hands and clothes. Soil has living and nonliving materials. The addition of leaves, sticks, pebbles, etc. should model how living and nonliving materials are found in soil.

    After students have spent time observing the contents of their bags, have them stop and bring their bags back to you. You will empty their bags back into the larger resealable plastic bag or a clear plastic container while students wash their hands and use hand sanitizer to kill microbial growth from the soil. This material will be used in the next day’s activity.

    Activity 2, Day 2

    In this investigation students will observe the soil from their newly crushed material made previously and compare it with soil found in the schoolyard. Take a small container and trowel and go with the class to a selected area. Get 2 cups of soil and place it in the small container. Have students observe both the container of crushed material and the container of soil collected. Record students’ responses on a chart or Venn diagram (S-3-3-2_Rock and Soil Venn Diagram.doc).

    Place two 1-liter clear soda containers on a flat surface and fill both 2/3 full of water. Using a funnel, carefully pour about 2 cups of soil collected from the schoolyard into one of the 1-liter containers. Next, carefully pour about 2 cups of the “student” made soil into the container. Have students observe the two containers as the soil is placed in each. Ask, “What is happening when the soil is put in the container? What happens when the containers are shaken? How will the bottles look tomorrow?”

    Make sure the tops are secure and then vigorously shake each container. Once the contents of the bottles are mixed, place each container in an undisturbed area and let the contents set for 24 hours. After 24 hours, students observe and record what they see on the Dirt Observation Sheet (S-3-3-2_Dirt Observation Sheet.doc).

    Display the two containers in this lesson. Ask students the following questions:

    Do both containers look alike?”

    What can you find in soil?”

    Do you think soil is renewable or a nonrenewable resource found on earth? Why?”

    What is the recipe for soil?” Soil must contain minerals, decayed plant and animals, water and air.

    What must soil have that dirt does not?” You want students to understand that dirt is weathered rock and soil is both weathered material (minerals) and decayed plants and animals.

    Soil is made up of 25% water, 25% air, 5% organic matter (dead plants and animals) and 45% rock. What parts of this soil recipe are nonliving? What parts are living? Which of our soils would you think is best for living things? What would you do if your soil did not have a good recipe?”

    Take a spoonful of this mixture and add a spoonful of potting soil, sand, pebbles, and more rocks and place in a small container. Add a bean seed and place in sunlight and monitor for water. Have students observe the seed throughout this unit. Compare the bean seed’s growth with the bean seed that was planted in Lesson 1.

    Extension:

    • Students who are going beyond the standards can collect soil from home, place it in a clear soda container, and repeat the layering process. Have students compare the samples with those at school. Determine if they are the same or different. What might be the reasons they are the same or different?

    • Students going beyond the standards can look at a soil pie chart. Have students color the nonliving parts of soil one color and the living parts of soil another color.

    • Students who might need opportunities for additional learning can gather rocks from home and compare them with class rocks. They can rub the rocks together and observe the small particles.

Related Instructional Videos

Note: Video playback may not work on all devices.
Instructional videos haven't been assigned to the lesson plan.
DRAFT 11/15/2010
Loading
Please wait...

Insert Template

Information