Skip to Main Content

Literary Criticism and Logical Fallacy

Unit Plan

Literary Criticism and Logical Fallacy

Objectives

In this unit, students will focus on persuasion, propaganda, and logical fallacies. Students will:

  • examine persuasive and propaganda techniques to evaluate their effectiveness in meeting an author’s purpose within a text.
  • identify characteristics of the political cartoon genre.
  • examine traits of advertisements.
  • build on understanding of persuasive techniques to explore logical fallacies.
  • use Socratic inquiry and reasoning patterns.

Essential Questions

  • How does interaction with text provoke thinking and response?

Related Unit and Lesson Plans

Related Materials & Resources

The possible inclusion of commercial websites below is not an implied endorsement of their products, which are not free, and are not required for this lesson plan.

Materials haven't been entered into the unit plan.

Formative Assessment

  • View

    Multiple-Choice Items

    1.      “March Madness” sale at a store is using which propaganda technique?

    A

    emotional appeal

    B

    kairos

    C

    logical fallacy

    D

    weasel words

    2.      An Olympic gold medal-winning swimmer encouraging people to eat Wheaties is an example of

    A

    authority.

    B

    a red herring.

    C

    a testimonial.

    D

    name-calling.

    3.      In 1925, the Coca-Cola slogan was “the sociable drink.” Which persuasion technique did that slogan use?

    A

    bandwagon

    B

    statistics

    C

    testimonial

    D

    tech talk

    Multiple-Choice Answer Key

    1. B

    2. C

    3. A

     

     

    Short-Answer Item:

    Write a paragraph that defines logical fallacy and describes at least three examples of logical fallacies that occur in arguments or propaganda.

    Short-Answer Key and Scoring Rubric:

    Points

    Description

    3

    Student completes all requirements by writing a paragraph that:

    • defines logical fallacy as a mistake in reasoning
    • describes at least three of the following types of logical fallacies that may occur in arguments or propaganda:

    o   faulty syllogism

    o   sweeping generalization

    o   circular reasoning/begging the question

    o   non sequitur

    o   post hoc ergo propter hoc

    o   loaded question

    o   straw man

    2

    • Student completes two of the requirements.

    1

    • Student completes one of the requirements.

    0

    • Student does not complete any of the requirements or does not attempt to complete the task. 

     


    Performance Assessment:

    Evaluate whether each student completed all individual written assignments for the unit assessment portfolio.

    Performance Assessment Scoring Rubric:

    Points

    Description

    3

    Student’s unit assessment portfolio includes all required assignments:

    • two or three political cartoons with accurate analysis
    • ten advertisements with accurate analysis of persuasive techniques
    • philosophical dialogue with fallacies identified and countered

    2

    Student’s unit assessment portfolio includes two of the required assignments.

    1

    Student’s unit assessment portfolio includes one of the required assignments.

    0

    Student’s unit assessment portfolio includes none of the required assignments.

     

     

DRAFT 06/14/2011
Loading
Please wait...